The IRS has announced a second Voluntary Disclosure Program for employers to resolve erroneous claims for credit or refund involving the COVID-19 Employee Retention Credit (ERC). Participation in the second ERC Voluntary Disclosure Program is limited to ERC claims filed for the 2021 tax period(s), and cannot be used to disclose and repay ERC money from tax periods in 2020.

The IRS has announced a second Voluntary Disclosure Program for employers to resolve erroneous claims for credit or refund involving the COVID-19 Employee Retention Credit (ERC). Participation in the second ERC Voluntary Disclosure Program is limited to ERC claims filed for the 2021 tax period(s), and cannot be used to disclose and repay ERC money from tax periods in 2020.

The program is designed to help businesses with questionable claims to self-correct and repay the credits they received after filing erroneous ERC claims, many of which were driven by aggressive marketing from unscrupulous promoters.

The first ERC Voluntary Disclosure Program was announced in late December 2023, and ended on March 22, 2024 (Announcement 2024-3, I.R.B. 2024-2, 364). Over 2,600 taxpayers applied to the first program to resolve their improper ERC claims and avoid civil penalties and unnecessary litigation.

The second ERC Voluntary Disclosure Program will allow businesses to correct improper payments at a 15-percent discount, and avoid future audits, penalties and interest.

Procedures for Second Voluntary Disclosure Program

To apply, employers must file Form 15434, Application for Employee Retention Credit Voluntary Disclosure Program, and submit it through the IRS Document Upload Tool. Employers must provide the IRS with the names, addresses, telephone numbers and details about the services provided by any advisors or tax preparers who advised or assisted them with their claims, and are expected to repay their full ERC claimed, minus the 15-percent reduction allowed through the Voluntary Disclosure Program.

Eligible employers must apply by 11:59 pm local time on November 22, 2024.

The Department of the Treasury and the IRS released statistics on the Inflation Reduction Act clean energy tax credits for the 2023 tax year. Taxpayers have claimed over $6 billion in tax credits for residential clean energy investments and more than $2 billion for energy-efficient home improvements on 2023 tax returns filed and processed through May 23, 2024.

The Department of the Treasury and the IRS released statistics on the Inflation Reduction Act clean energy tax credits for the 2023 tax year. Taxpayers have claimed over $6 billion in tax credits for residential clean energy investments and more than $2 billion for energy-efficient home improvements on 2023 tax returns filed and processed through May 23, 2024.

For the Residential Clean Energy Credit, 1,246,440 returns were filed, with a total credit value of $6.3 billion and an average of $5,084 per return. Specific investments include:

• Rooftop solar: 752,300 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost;
• Batteries: 48,840 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost.

For the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit, 2,338,430 returns were filed, with a total credit value of $2.1 billion and an average of $882 per return. Specific improvements include:

• Home insulation: 669,440 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost;
• Windows and skylights: 694,450 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost or $600;
• Central air conditioners: 488,050 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost or $600;
• Doors: 400,070 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost, $250 per door or $500 total;
• Heat pumps: 267,780 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost or $2,000;
• Heat pump water heaters: 104,180 returns, up to 30 percent of the cost or $2,000.

Internal Revenue Service Commissioner Daniel Werfel is calling on Congress to maintain the agency’s funding and not make any further cuts to the supplemental funding provided to the agency in the Inflation Reduction Act, using recent successes in customer service and compliance to validate his request.

Internal Revenue Service Commissioner Daniel Werfel is calling on Congress to maintain the agency’s funding and not make any further cuts to the supplemental funding provided to the agency in the Inflation Reduction Act, using recent successes in customer service and compliance to validate his request.

"The Inflation Reduction Act funding is making a difference for taxpayers, and we will build on these improvements in the months ahead," Werfel said during a July 24, 2024, press teleconference, adding that "for this progress to continue, we must maintain a reliable, consistent annual appropriations for the agency as well as keeping the Inflation Reduction Act funding intact."

During the call, Werfel highlighted a number of improvements to IRS operations that have come about due to the IRA funding, including expansion of online account features (such as providing more digital forms, making it easier to make online payments, and making access in general easier); providing more access to taxpayers wanting face-to-face assistance (including a 37 percent increase in interactions at taxpayer assistance centers); IT modernization; and the collection of more than $1 billion in taxes due form high wealth individuals.

Werfel did highlight an area where he would like to see some improvements, including the number of taxpayers who have activated their online account.

While he did not have a number of how many taxpayers have activated their accounts so far, he said that “"we are nowhere near where we have the opportunity to be,"” adding that as functionality improves and expands, that will bring more taxpayers in to use their online accounts and other digital services.

He also noted that online accounts will be a deterrent for scams, and it will provide taxpayers with the information they need to not be fooled by scammers.

“We see the online account as a real way to test these scams and schemes because taxpayers will have a single source of truth about whether they actually owe a debt, whether the IRS is trying to reach them, and also information we can push out to taxpayers more regularly if they sign up and opt in for it on the latest scams and schemes,” Werfel said.

By Gregory Twachtman, Washington News Editor

The IRS has intensified its efforts to scrutinize claims for the Employee Retention Credit (ERC), issuing five new warning signs of incorrect claims. These warning signs, based on common issues observed by IRS compliance teams, are in addition to seven problem areas previously highlighted by the agency. Businesses with pending or previously approved claims are urged to carefully review their filings to confirm eligibility and ensure credits claimed do not include any of these twelve warning signs or other mistakes. The IRS emphasizes the importance of consulting a trusted tax professional rather than promoters to ensure compliance with ERC rules.

The IRS has intensified its efforts to scrutinize claims for the Employee Retention Credit (ERC), issuing five new warning signs of incorrect claims. These warning signs, based on common issues observed by IRS compliance teams, are in addition to seven problem areas previously highlighted by the agency. Businesses with pending or previously approved claims are urged to carefully review their filings to confirm eligibility and ensure credits claimed do not include any of these twelve warning signs or other mistakes. The IRS emphasizes the importance of consulting a trusted tax professional rather than promoters to ensure compliance with ERC rules.

The newly identified issues include essential businesses claiming ERC despite being fully operational, unsupported government order suspensions, misreporting wages paid to family members, using wages already forgiven under the Paycheck Protection Program, and large employers incorrectly claiming wages for employees who provided services. The IRS plans to deny tens of thousands of claims that show clear signs of being erroneous and scrutinize hundreds of thousands more that may be incorrect. In addition, the IRS announced upcoming compliance measures and details about reopening the Voluntary Disclosure Program, aimed at addressing high-risk ERC claims and processing low-risk payments to help small businesses with legitimate claims.

IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel emphasized the agency’s commitment to pursuing improper claims and increasing payments to businesses with legitimate claims. Promoters lured many businesses into mistakenly claiming the ERC, leading to the IRS digitizing and analyzing approximately 1 million ERC claims, representing over $86 billion. The IRS urges businesses to act promptly to resolve incorrect claims, avoiding future issues such as audits, repayment, penalties, and interest. Taxpayers should recheck their claims with the help of trusted tax professionals, considering options such as the ERC Withdrawal Program or amending their returns to correct overclaimed amounts.

The IRS, in collaboration with state tax agencies and the national tax industry, has initiated a new effort to tackle the rising threat of tax-related scams. This initiative, named the Coalition Against Scam and Scheme Threats (CASST), was launched in response to a significant increase in fraudulent activities during the most recent tax filing season. These scams have targeted both individual taxpayers and government systems, seeking to exploit vulnerabilities for financial gain.

The IRS, in collaboration with state tax agencies and the national tax industry, has initiated a new effort to tackle the rising threat of tax-related scams. This initiative, named the Coalition Against Scam and Scheme Threats (CASST), was launched in response to a significant increase in fraudulent activities during the most recent tax filing season. These scams have targeted both individual taxpayers and government systems, seeking to exploit vulnerabilities for financial gain.

CASST will focus on three primary objectives: enhancing public outreach and education to alert taxpayers to emerging threats, developing new methods to identify fraudulent returns at the point of filing, and improving the infrastructure to protect taxpayers and the integrity of the tax system. This initiative builds on the successful framework of the Security Summit, which was launched in 2015 to combat tax-related identity theft. While the Security Summit made significant progress in reducing identity theft, CASST aims to address a broader range of scams, reflecting the evolving tactics of fraudsters.

The coalition has received widespread support, with over 60 private sector groups, including leading software and financial companies, joining the effort. Key national tax professional organizations are also participating, all committed to strengthening the security of the tax system.

Among the measures CASST will implement are enhanced validation processes for tax preparers, including improvements to the Electronic Filing Identification Number (EFIN) and Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN) systems. The coalition will also target the issue of ghost preparers, who prepare tax returns for a fee without proper disclosure, leading to inflated refunds and significant revenue losses.

In addition to these technical improvements, CASST will address specific scams, such as fraudulent claims for tax credits like the Fuel Tax Credit. By the 2025 filing season, CASST aims to have new protections in place, bolstering defenses across both public and private sectors to make it more difficult for scammers to exploit the tax system. This coordinated effort seeks to protect taxpayers and ensure the integrity of the nation’s tax system.

The Internal Revenue Service will be processing about 50,000 "low-risk" Employee Retention Credit claims, and it will be shifting the moratorium dates on processing.

The Internal Revenue Service will be processing about 50,000 "low-risk"Employee Retention Credit claims, and it will be shifting the moratorium dates on processing.

"The IRS projects payments will begin in September with additional payments going out in subsequent weeks," the agency said in an August 8, 2024, statement."The IRS anticipates adding another large block of additional low-risk claims for processing and payment in the fall."

The agency also announced that it is shifting the moratorium period on processing new claims. Originally, the agency was not processing claims that were filed after September 14, 2023. It is now going to process claims filed between September 14, 2023, and January 31, 2024.

"Like the rest of the ERC inventory, work will focus on the highest and lowest risk claims at the top and bottom end of the spectrum," the IRS said. "This means there will be instances where the agency will start taking actions on claims submitted in this time period when the agency has seen a sound basis to pay or deny any refund claim."

The agency also said it has sent out "28,000 disallowance letters to businesses whose claims showed a high risk of being incorrect," preventing up to $5 billion in improper payments. It also has "thousands of audits underway, and 460 criminal cases have been initiated" with potentially fraudulent claims worth nearly $7 billion. Thirty-seven investigations have resulted in federal charges, with 17 resulting in convictions.

Businesses that receive a denial letter will have the ability to appeal the decision.

The agency also offered some other updates on the ERC program, including:

• The claim withdrawal process for unprocessed ERC has led to more than 7,300 withdrawing $677 million in claims;
• The voluntary disclosure program received more than 2,600 applications from ERC recipients that disclosed $1.09 billion in credits; and
• The IRS Office of Promoter Investigations has received "hundreds" of referrals about suspected abusive tax promoters and preparers improperly promoting the ability to claim the ERC.

"The IRS is committed to continuing out work to resolve this program as Congress contemplates further action, both for the good of legitimate businesses and tax administration," IRS Commissioner Daniel Werfel said in the statement.

By Gregory Twachtman, Washington News Editor

The IRS has announced substantial progress in its ongoing efforts to modernize tax administration, emphasizing a shift towards digital interactions and enhanced measures to combat tax evasion. This update, part of a broader 10-year plan supported by the Inflation Reduction Act, reflects the agency's commitment to improving taxpayer services and ensuring fairer compliance.

The IRS has announced substantial progress in its ongoing efforts to modernize tax administration, emphasizing a shift towards digital interactions and enhanced measures to combat tax evasion. This update, part of a broader 10-year plan supported by the Inflation Reduction Act, reflects the agency's commitment to improving taxpayer services and ensuring fairer compliance.

The IRS’s push for digital transformation has seen significant advancements, allowing taxpayers to conduct nearly all interactions with the agency online. This initiative aims to reduce the reliance on paper submissions, expedite tax processing, and improve overall efficiency. In 2024 alone, the IRS introduced extended hours at Taxpayer Assistance Centers across the country, particularly benefiting rural and underserved communities. The agency also reported a notable increase in face-to-face interactions, with a 37 percent rise in contacts during the 2024 filing season.

In parallel with these service improvements, the IRS has ramped up efforts to disrupt complex tax evasion schemes. Leveraging advanced data science and technology, the agency has focused on high-income individuals and entities employing sophisticated financial maneuvers to avoid taxes. Among the IRS’s new measures is a moratorium on processing Employee Retention Credit claims to prevent fraud, alongside initiatives targeting abusive use of partnerships and improper corporate practices.

The IRS also highlighted its progress in eliminating paper filings through the introduction of the Document Upload Tool, which allows taxpayers to submit documents electronically. This tool, along with upgraded scanning and mail-sorting equipment, is expected to significantly reduce the volume of paper correspondence, potentially replacing millions of paper documents each year. These technological upgrades are part of the IRS’s broader goal to create a fully digital workflow, thereby speeding up refunds and improving service accuracy.

Additionally, the IRS has launched new programs to ensure taxpayers are informed about and can claim eligible credits and deductions. This includes outreach efforts related to the Child Tax Credit and the Earned Income Tax Credit, aiming to bridge the gap for eligible taxpayers who may not have claimed these benefits. These initiatives underline the IRS's dedication to a more equitable tax system, ensuring that all taxpayers have access to the credits and services they are entitled to while maintaining robust compliance standards.

The IRS has provided guidance regarding whether taxpayers receiving loans under the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) may deduct otherwise deductible expenses. Act Sec. 1106(i) of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act ( P.L. 116-136) did not address whether generally allowable deductions such as those under Code Secs. 162 and 163 would still be permitted if the loan was later forgiven pursuant to Act Sec. 1106(b). The IRS has found that such deductions are not permissible.

The IRS has provided guidance regarding whether taxpayers receiving loans under the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) may deduct otherwise deductible expenses. Act Sec. 1106(i) of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act ( P.L. 116-136) did not address whether generally allowable deductions such as those under Code Secs. 162 and 163 would still be permitted if the loan was later forgiven pursuant to Act Sec. 1106(b). The IRS has found that such deductions are not permissible.

PPP Loans
The CARES Act expanded the Small Business Administration’s (SBA’s) existing Section 7(a) loan program to include certain PPP loans. The PPP is made available from the SBA to provide small businesses with loans to help pay payroll costs, mortgages, rent, and utilities during the COVID-19 (coronavirus) crisis. All payments of principal, interest, and fees under the loans are deferred for at least 6 months. The loans are also forgiven for amounts payroll costs, mortgage or rent obligations, and certain utility payments incurred between February 15 and June 30. The loans are 100 percent guaranteed by the SBA.

Deductions Prohibited
If the SBA forgives a taxpayer’s PPP loan pursuant to Act. Sec. 1106(b) of the CARES Act, the amount of the loan is excluded from gross income. Under Reg. §1.265-1 taxpayers cannot deduct expenses that are allocable to income that is either wholly excluded from gross income or wholly exempt from the taxes. This rule exists in order to prevent double tax benefits. Thus, the IRS has determined that taxpayers who have their PPP loans forgiven may not deduct any business or interest expenses related to the income associated with the loan.

Treasury and the Small Business Administration (SBA) have worked together to release the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Forgiveness Application. According to Treasury’s May 15 press release, the application and correlating instructions inform borrowers how to apply for forgiveness of PPP loans under the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Act ( P.L. 116-136). The PPP was enacted under the CARES Act to provide eligible small businesses with loans during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Treasury and the Small Business Administration (SBA) have worked together to release the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) Loan Forgiveness Application. According to Treasury’s May 15 press release, the application and correlating instructions inform borrowers how to apply for forgiveness of PPP loans under the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Act ( P.L. 116-136). The PPP was enacted under the CARES Act to provide eligible small businesses with loans during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Additionally, SBA is expected to issue regulations and guidance to assist borrowers as they complete their applications, and to provide lenders with guidance on their responsibilities, according to Treasury.

Measures included in the application and instructions intended to reduce compliance burdens and simplify the process for borrowers include:

• options to calculate payroll costs using an "alternative payroll covered period" that aligns with borrowers’ regular payroll cycles;
• flexibility to include eligible payroll and non-payroll expenses paid or incurred during the eight-week period after receiving their PPP loan;
• step-by-step instructions on how to perform the calculations required by the CARES Act to confirm eligibility for loan forgiveness;
• borrower-friendly implementation of statutory exemptions from loan forgiveness reduction based on rehiring by June 30; and
• the addition of a new exemption from the loan forgiveness reduction for borrowers who have made a good-faith, written offer to rehire workers that was declined.

Although you may want your traditional individual retirement accounts (IRAs) to keep accumulating tax-free well into your old age, the IRS sets certain deadlines. The price for getting an upfront deduction when contributing to a traditional IRA (or having a rollover IRA) is that Uncle Sam eventually starts taxing it once you reach 70½. The required minimum distribution (RMD) rules under the Internal Revenue Code accomplish that.

If distributions do not meet the strict minimum requirements for any one year once you reach 70½, you must pay an excise tax equal to 50 percent, even if you kept the money in the account by mistake.

Required minimum distribution

The traditional IRA owner must begin receiving a minimum amount of distributions (the RMD) from his or her IRA by April 1 of the year following the year in which he or she reaches age 70½. That first deadline is referred to as the required beginning date.

If, in any year, you as a traditional IRA owner receive more than the RMD for that year, you will not receive credit for the additional amount when determining the RMD for future years. However, any amount distributed in your 70½ year will be credited toward the amount that must be distributed by April 1 of the following year. The RMD for any year after the year you turn 70½ must be made by December 31 of that year.

Distribution period

The distribution period is the maximum number of years over which you are allowed to take distributions from the IRA. You calculate your RMD for each year by dividing the amount in the IRA as of the close of business on December 31 of the preceding year by your life expectancy at that time as set by special IRS tables. Those tables are found in IRS Publication 590, "IRAs Appendix C."

Example: Say you were born on November 1, 1936, are unmarried, and have a traditional IRA. Since you have reached age 70½ in 2007 (on May 1 to be exact), your required beginning date is April 1, 2008. Assume further that as of December 31, 2006, your account balance was $26,500. Using Table III, the applicable distribution period for someone your age as of December 31, 2007 (when you will be age 71) is 26.5 years. Your RMD for 2007 is $1,000 ($26,500 ÷ 26.5). That amount must be distributed to you by April 1, 2008.

The RMD rules do not apply to Roth IRAs; they only apply to traditional IRAs. That is one of the principal estate planning reasons for setting up a Roth IRA or rolling over a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. The downside of a Roth IRA, of course, is not getting an upfront deduction for contributions, or having to pay tax on the balance when rolled over from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA.

Please contact this office if you need any help in determining a RMD or in deciding whether a rollover to a Roth IRA now to avoid RMD issues later might make sense for you.

Q. I use my computer for both business and pleasure and I am confused about how much I can deduct. Also, how are PDAs such as Palm Pilots, etc. deducted for tax purposes?

A. Because computers and peripheral equipment are viewed as more susceptible than other business property to unwarranted deductions for personal use, they are subject to special scrutiny under the tax law. This scrutiny comes from their classification as "listed property," which limits the amount that may be deducted each year.

A computer as listed property only becomes an issue if it is not used exclusively in business. If a computer is used exclusively at the taxpayer's regular business establishment or in the taxpayer's principal trade or business, the listed property limitations don't apply at all.

Any computer that you use predominately for pleasure may not be written-off over its life nearly as quickly as exclusive-use computers. If your business usage does not meet the predominant use test, you are relegated to using a much slower depreciation method (the ADS, straight-line method) over the longer-ADS recovery period.

Your computer will meet the predominant use test for any tax year if its qualified business use is more than 50% of its total use. You must review your computer's usage and determine the percentage usage for each of its various uses (business, investment, and personal). When computing the predominant use test, any investment use of your computer cannot be considered as part of the percentage of qualified business use. However, you do use the combined total of business and investment use to figure your depreciation deduction for the property. It's up to you to prove business use to the IRS; the IRS does not need to prove personal use to reject your deductions.

In order to claim your computer expenses, you must meet the adequate records requirements by maintaining a "log" or other documentary evidence that sufficiently establishes the business/investment percentage claimed. The log should be similar to a log you would keep to track your auto expenses, indicating date, time of usage, business or nonbusiness, and business reason. Good documentation is always the key to success if your return is ever audited.

Finally, what about application of these rules to PDA's? The shorter the designated "life" of the property, the faster you can write-off its cost. Cell phones are generally considered 7-year property (the cost is depreciated over seven years). Computers are generally considered 5-year property, and computer-software normally is 3-year property. PDA's are generally classified as 5-year property, being considered wireless computers. If a PDA includes a cell phone feature, as long as that feature is not predominant and removable, it continues to fall under the 5-year property rule. Software that you may download to your PDA is 3-year property. Software that you buy already loaded into the PDA, however, is 5-year property. Monthly charges for a wireless service provider are deductible as paid each month, just as your business would deduct any phone or internet service bill.

Most homeowners have found that over the past five to ten years, real estate -especially the home in which they live-- has proven to be a great investment. When the 1997 Tax Law passed, most homeowners assumed that the eventual sale of their home would be tax free. At that time, Congress exempted from tax at least $250,000 of gain on the sale of a principal residence; $500,000 if a joint return was filed. Now, those exemption amounts, which are not adjusted for inflation, don't seem too generous for many homeowners.

What can be done?

Keeping lots of receipts is one answer! Remember, it will be the gain on your home that is potentially taxable, not full sale price. Gain is equal to net sales price minus an amount equal to the price you paid for your house (including mortgage debt) plus the cost of any improvements made over the years. Bottom line: If your residence has gain that will otherwise be taxed, you will get around 30 percent back on the cost of the improvements (assume your tax bracket is about 30 percent when you sell), simply by keeping good records of those improvements.

The basis of your personal residence is generally made up of three basic components: original cost, improvements, and certain other basis adjustments

How your home was acquired will need to be considered when determining its original cost basis.

Purchase or Construction. If you bought your home, your original cost basis will generally include the purchase price of the property and most settlement or closing costs you paid. If you or someone else constructed your home, your basis in the home would be your basis in the land plus the amount you paid to have the home built, including any settlement and closing costs incurred to acquire the land or secure a loan.

Gift. If you acquired your home as a gift, your basis will be the same as it would be in the hands of the donor at the time it was given to you.

Inheritance. If you inherited your home, your basis is the fair market value on the date of the deceased's death or on the "alternate valuation" date, as indicated on the federal estate tax return filed for the deceased.

Divorce. If your home was transferred to you from your ex-spouse incident to your divorce, your basis is the same as the ex-spouse's adjusted basis just before the transfer took place.

If you've been in your home any length of time, you most likely have made some home improvements. These improvements will generally increase your home's basis and therefore decrease any potential gain on the sale of your residence. Before you increase your basis for any home improvements, though, you will need to determine which expenditures can actually be considered improvements versus repairs.

An improvement materially adds to the value of your home, considerably prolongs its useful life, or adapts it to new uses. The cost of any improvements cannot be deducted and must be added to the basis of your home. Examples of improvements include putting room additions, putting up a fence, putting in new plumbing or wiring, installing a new roof, and resurfacing your patio. It doesn't need to be a big project, however, just relatively permanent. For example, putting in a skylight or a new kitchen sink qualifies.

Repairs, on the other hand, are expenses that are incurred to keep the property in a generally efficient operating condition and do not add value or extend the life of the property. For a personal residence, these costs do not add to the basis of the home. Examples of repairs are painting, mending drywall, and fixing a minor plumbing problem.

Additional items that will increase your basis include expenditures for restoring damaged property and assessing local improvements. Some common decreases to your home's basis are:

• Insurance reimbursements for casualty losses.
• Deductible casualty losses that aren't covered by insurance.
• Payments received for easement or right-of-way granted.
• Deferred gain(s) on previous home sales before 1998.
• Depreciation claimed after May 6, 1997 if you used your home for business or rental purposes.

In order to document your home's basis, it is wise to keep the records that substantiate the basis of your residence such as settlement statements, receipts, canceled checks, and other records for all improvements you made. Good records can make your life a lot easier if the IRS ever questions your gain calculation. You should keep these records for as long as you own the home. Once you sell the home, keep the records until the statute of limitations expires (generally three years after the date on which the return was filed reporting the sale).